Sunday, November 1, 2009

The Ethics of Consolation



For Colossus, in response to the situations I discussed in the last post, solace was found in the form of a tattoo (I'm still kicking myself for not having the issue this appeared in on hand to scan and include a picture of) or in the mindless fighting that bordered on deadly. For Wolverine it is often, surprisingly enough, found in a Japanese garden while meditating. Scott Summers (Cyclops), as seen in the third X-Men movie, attempts to find comfort in his sorrow by shutting himself off from the world. Spider-Man turned to his friends after the loss of a loved one. And Tony Stark, the hero known as Iron Man...usually just drowns his pain with alcohol.

Everyone deals with loss and pain in different ways. Superheroes are no different, and it is in times of pain that they demonstrate the humanity that so often seems hidden from us. Heroes behind masks often seem inaccessible to the masses (almost none of the adults I talk to, adults who got to live during the golden age of comic books understands what is so very real about these characters), yet when they are encountering loss it is easy for us to see ourselves in them. Mark Millar has recently taken a spin on the comic book hero we are accustomed to. In his acclaimed series Kick-Ass (soon to be a major motion picture...get excited...maybe) Millar brings us the tale of Dave Lizewski, a very ordinary high school student who chooses to become a super hero. After all, how hard can it be? He's read the literature (comic books of course), and his heart is in the right place...what else is there to the business of heroism? Lizewski dons a mask and steps into the night to fight crime...he gets beaten to a pulp and barely escapes the ordeal alive. Yet he persists...and eventually finds some degree of success as a hero. Now I'm sure there will be plenty of failure to come, but I have been unable to read the recent issues of the story as I am a poor college student and am waiting for the trade paperback to be released so I can afford it. Still, there is much to be examined in this story.


Consolation for Dave Lizewski comes in the form of a mask. While he is not dealing with loss per say, he is dealing with pain. The pain of being ordinary, pain of discontent. Lizewski is just an average student, if that, the girl he likes barely notices him, and his single dad is barely around. He retreats behind the mask because it makes him something more, something that people take notice of. The problem involved with this, and many forms of consolation, is that it can become an idol, and I think in the case of Dave Lizewski this is the case. Is the point here that heroism is wrong? Of course not, nor am I saying that seeking out friends or family or any other form of consolation is wrong. However, that should not be our first and only option.


As the Bible says, God is a comforting God. Take Isaiah 40:11 for example, "He will feed his flock like a shepherd, he will gather the lambs in his arms, he will carry them in his bosom, and gently lead those that are with young." Exodus 20:3 commands us to have no other gods apart from God. In regards to idolatry, I don't mean to say for a second that when we find comfort outside of God it is wrong, however this is often what happens. Idolatry is defined as "blind or excessive devotion to something", in Lizewski's case, a mask that allows him to do heroic deeds. God is to be our comfort, but if we take comfort in other things I still think that is perfectly fine. However, we should not place our trust and devotion in these items of solace. Our hope should not rest in people or things, it should remain with God.

'Nuff Said
-Cable

No comments:

Post a Comment